Every child has a right to an education. Federal as well as New York law ensure that all public school students are entitled to something called general due process if they are suspended. While not as extensive as the kind of due process given criminal offenders under our constitution, courts have said that all students must be given the right to confront witnesses and present their side of the story in a hearing before this right may be taken away.  (Due process also means different things in a private school setting.)

In New York, there are additional rights that students have based on state statutes, regulations and local law (often the school's Code of Conduct).

It is always advisable for parents to read what is on their school's and district's website in regards to parent and student handbooks as well as codes of conduct so they better understand how their school handles disciplinary violations. Some schools are very strict—especially in the upper grades—due to the large size of those schools. Others are less strict, but still have some rules as schools are aware of the studies stating that correcting issues early on or in elementary school is easier than trying to correct them in middle and high school (although some illnesses, and/or teenage hormones, will create different issues that aren't foreseeable, which is something the school should take into account and be ready to be less punishing and more nurturing).

In general the greater the threatened punishment, the greater the amount of due process a child is afforded.

It is always advisable to see your child's records once per year prior to any shredding that may take place, as there may be minor disciplinary infractions on their record of which you were unaware. These disciplinary records are available in the superintendent's office usually.

At the start of any complaint by staff or another student, against your child the school will do an investigation, which may involve speaking to your child without your consent. They are allowed to do this in limited circumstances. However, they may not do so if your child has a disability and you have previously indicated in a letter or in the child's IEP that during any disciplinary infraction you must be called when the school wants to speak to your child, or if the child cannot understand what is being asked of him. They may even ask your child to sign a statement, which many children will do, sometimes without knowing what they are signing. Children need to be made aware they do not have to talk or sign anything. They may not involve police in their interrogations, however.

If a child is given a detention, he has a right to know what it is for and to dispute the charge. A teacher removal for bad behavior gives a child certain rights as well which include meeting with the principal. If the punishment is an in-school suspension, the child and parent have a right to know the charges, meet with the principal and tell their side of the story. With out-of-school suspensions, a phone call should be made prior to whenever the decision to suspend has been made and obviously subsequent to any investigation but in any event within 24 hours of the decision to suspend.

 A letter must be sent home if the child is given an out-of-school suspension of five days or less, which clearly states the charges, the parent and child's right to meet with the principal, confront the witness, and tell their side of the story. There should also be information in the letter regarding the right to appeal the decision and timelines for these short suspensions can be VERY short—as little as five days--but the Code of Conduct will usually indicate this, too. You also have a right to request to see any videotape that was made during the time you have the conference or at the school's office.

If, during this time the parent receives a letter that the school's investigation has determined a hearing must take place (not uncommon where there already has been a short-term out of school suspension on the same charge), the parent has the right to a hearing on the facts, which in many cases is much like the principal's meeting, however the school's attorney is present and a parent may also have an attorney present (and may get a one-time change in date to find one). There will be an upper level administrator/contracted hearing officer who will hear the facts and make a determination as to the child's guilt or innocence, plus a transcriptionist or recorder to record the hearing. The end result may be a long-term suspension of greater than 5 days, but usually weeks or months.

The parent may bring anyone they want to the hearing in order to submit evidence of good behavior and possible excuses for the behavior at the penalty part of the hearing (mitigating factors). However, a parent should know that the hearing officers themselves most often are school personnel or former school personnel and tend to think like administrators, which is to say, they enforce the rules in order to set an example.

Solutions like restorative justice (allowing the child to make amends to the community in a specific and teachable moment) are an excellent example of something that could be used when the conduct is not egregious, e.g. for short-term or in-school suspensions, but otherwise the school is looking to punish the student and/or to remove the student from the school in order to calm things down.

However, in these times, long term suspension hearings (otherwise called Section 3214 or superintendent's hearings) are most likely to result where drugs, guns or other violent or serious behavior is involved. Getting an attorney is helpful as these hearings must be held within the first five days of suspension without a request for an extension (adjournment), and it is difficult to gather facts in that time. Once adjourned, the child must wait weeks for a rescheduled hearing, during which time he is not allowed the same number of hours of instruction, unless he is a special education student, in which case he is entitled to education to compensate for the missing hours. However, it may give the parties time to gather evidence and work things out. Also, parents and school may benefit from attorney intervention where there has been a breakdown in communication between the parties.

If a child has an IEP or 504 plan, they may be entitled to a manifestation hearing, in which the CSE team asks whether the IEP was implemented correctly, and whether the child's behavior was a manifestation of his or her disability. This applies when suspensions in excess of 10 days have taken place, however, see below. Services and a free appropriate public education must be provided during this time to students with an IEP. Depending on the outcome, this may bring relief from the charges. If the team finds the child's behavior is a manifestation of his disability or the behavior plan or IEP was not followed, the child is not penalized for his or her behavior.

Further, if your child has an IEP or 504 plan the school may not suspend to avoid implementing or revising the child's behavioral plan, or to avoid doing additional assessments that may reveal information that can be utilized in obtaining a free appropriate education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE). Finally, your child may not be interviewed alone if it impacts his or her disability, i.e. he or she is unable to understand the questioning, the charges, what he is being asked to sign, or is likely to get anxious or sick from being held in an office against his or her will. You, as a parent, have a right to have this be part of your child's IEP and should insist on it.

During the hearing, while the school's attorney will take the lead, be aware that your child does not have the same rights as a person who is in criminal court. If in fact there are criminal charges pending in juvenile court, the child should not take the stand. He does not have to admit to anything in the hearing but the school's attorney must prove his case with enough evidence—not beyond a reasonable doubt—but something called preponderence of the evidence. In many cases, the school's attorney is a skilled litigator and children will be traumatized by the experience of taking the stand, so it is not advisable unless the child is older and wants to do it.

There are few court rules, although you can object to relevancy (whether evidence matters), any kind of behavior by the school that seems unfair, or does not seem to be part of the code of conduct in the way it was enforced or the way it was written in the letter. If there is badgering of the witness, say so. If you, the parent, have a disability, make sure you ask the school for reasonable accommodations, like breaks, beforehand. An attorney can help with other strategies based on emerging caselaw, but this is a start.

During the hearing the burden of proving the child committed the act is on the school district, who will present their case and interview their main witness. They only have to prove things by a preponderance of the evidence, not as a high a standard as criminal court. The hearing officer may ask questions, and you are allowed to cross examine school's witness, as well as present your own.

After this, if there is no manifestation hearing, there will be an adjournment so the hearing officer can make a decision. If the decision is guilty, the parent is allowed to present the evidence of mitigating factors, as discussed above. If the decision is not made at the time of the hearing, or shortly thereafter, it may be an appeal issue.

You should, in any case, receive a letter shortly thereafter with the superintendent's stamp of approval telling you how many days you have to appeal the long-term suspension to the board of education, which should be 30 calendar days. If it is not, ask for an extension.

A board appeal is usually done on paper and it helps if it organized like a legal brief. After the board decides, there is another level of appeal. From the date of decision by the board, you have 30 calendar days to appeal to the commissioner. The commissioner's decision may be appealed to the New York Supreme Court.

In general, it is best to consult with an attorney for more information about a child's rights before, during and after a suspension hearing than can reasonably be covered in this newsletter, and for specific information on your child's situation. Please note that students with a 504 plan have less protection during a suspension than a student with an IEP plan.

Manifestation hearings for students with an IEP may be appealed to an impartial due process hearing officer appointed by the state within 20 days, otherwise known as an "expedited due process hearing". A recent decision regarding manifestation hearings for special education students gives an opportunity for students with disabilities to be provided with an additional level of review on the suspension hearing facts as well.   Those students may appeal the portions of their suspension hearings involving the facts of the case in addition to appealing the manifestation itself.

It is important to note that manifestation rules apply to private schools who are recipients of federal funds, as well.

A final note: It is worth noting that schools are able to remove a child for a period of 45 days if the child's behavior was particularly violent or of concern. However, the rules are beyond the scope of this newsletter of this newsletter and should be reviewed with a special education attorney.

Please feel free to re-use and re-distribute provided proper attribution is given to our office.

This newsletter is copyrighted and generated by the Law Office of Suzanne Myron and is intended as general legal advice for New York residents only. For individual advice, please consult with an attorney of your choice.

The Law Office of Suzanne Myron is located at 6800 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset, NY by appointment only. For further information, or to make an appointment, please call 516-864-3876 or 516-393-5955 or email smyron@myronlaw.com.



01/14/2016 9:41am

The federal, as well as New York law, ensures that all public school students are entitled to something called general due process if they are suspended. For me, this is the best and most interesting part of this post. Due process is very important, it is the legal requirement that the state must respect all legal rights that are owed to a person.Also, from Due Process of Law: A Brief History by John V. Orth, I have learned a lot here about due process. This describes how a commitment to fair procedures made way for an emphasis on the protection of rights, in general.

01/08/2017 8:35pm

EF13 Muscle Supplement you also need fats to achieve your muscle building goals. Many humans make the error of looking to keep away from fasts EF13 Muscle Supplement when they're running to construct muscle. Even if your intention is fats loss and muscle profits, you still need to eat sufficient fat. fats are critical to your frame, and sure styles of fats are vital for muscle boom, muscle restoration, joint health, mind characteristic, and greater. http://skulptekprofacts.com/ef13-muscle-supplement/

07/12/2016 6:42pm

In cases like this, an administrative due process must be rightfully exercised. Parents must be aware what their rights are in this process. Each parties have a right to enforce and observe. Any parent that finds the process unfairly carried out needs to be sure of what the infractions are. Thereafter, it can be elevated to the higher federal courts.

02/28/2017 10:03pm

Max Grow Xtreme as the outcomes of these capsules are very herbal as they are also very cheap as examine to branded capsules.however don desire Max Grow Xtreme to spend an awful lot amount for the treatment of such sexual sickness.


12/09/2016 3:16am

It's important to know your rights. This post is extremely useful and informative.

03/01/2017 8:49pm

Beard Czar as it's miles difficult to distribute it frivolously. any there are numerous other alternatives with a purpose to defend your hair from ultraviolet rays of Beard Czar the solar and they're hat and a few styling merchandise with silicone.


12/16/2016 8:56pm

ShowBox App for iPhone, *iPad | Download ShowBox on iOS:
Before you can download Showbox make sure you go through this step:-
Go to Settings > Security > Turn on Unknown Sources (This step may vary depending on your device version but basically you will need to turn on the option that allows you to install non-market apps).
5 Best Showbox Alternatives and Similar Apps:

12/19/2016 4:27am

Indian Flag – Significance of Colors, Ashoka chakra, and Features:
The Significance of Tricolor of the Indian Flag :
The Do’s and Dont’s of the Indian flag:
Who designed National Flag ?
India Flag – History of National Flag and Some Important Facts:
Indian National Flag – The Tricolor:
Things about India Flag – All Indians Need to Know:
Important Facts: All Indians must know about the India Flag:

03/02/2017 8:27pm

Apex Vitality Booty Pop for is companies which can be presenting you outcomes that sound too desirable to be genuine frequently if their claims appear too properly Apex Vitality Booty Pop to be actual they likely are and the enterprise is trying to make a brief greenback.


03/03/2017 8:22pm

Priamax Male Enhancement benefits from this form of capsules like appetite controlling easy and fast manner to free weight. at present weight reduction capsules Priamax Male Enhancement assist overweight humans in united kingdom and Europe to get rid from this epidemic disease.


03/06/2017 12:11am

Max Grow Xtreme apart from a fashionable physical exam you is probably requested to behavior a few laboratory tests for urine and blood so that underlying clinical cause Max Grow Xtreme may be diagnosed. you can also check out for some online erectile.


03/06/2017 8:34pm

Beard Czar it about ensuring that your hair and scalp is balanced the usage of herbal products combined with your hair personal herbal oils to provide you that Beard Czar commercial worth head of hair.there are some brands obtainable primarily.


03/07/2017 8:43pm

Priamax Male Enhancement marketing inputs and outputs. the advertising output is eviller and och advertising and marketing which offers in marketing of china Priamax Male Enhancement trade merchandise. the modern form of wholesale and retail markets have advanced.


03/08/2017 8:36pm

Testo Ultra do you truly plan to get married and in how lengthy you have to first discover those answers in your self and ultimately let your date know.boost your self Testo Ultra assurance through the above recommendations.


03/09/2017 8:51pm

Better Beard Club there also are a huge variety of clip in hair extension products on the market that are extraordinary for converting the manner you look in Better Beard Club just a few moments and can be fitted and brought out as and when you please.


03/10/2017 8:28pm

Better Beard Club there also are dioxin treatments available that help make stronger your hair from follicle to tip. the difference that dioxin products have from the other Better Beard Club products is that while other products generally tend to coat the hair.


03/13/2017 10:16pm

Pure Nitro Max builds muscle correctly at some point of your body. it takes just half-hour to put together a exercising and construct muscle for your legs Pure Nitro Max buttocks chest shoulders and fingers. and with the compact length an elliptical builds.


03/14/2017 9:27pm

Nitrobuild Plus youngsters are eating speedy meals and gaining weight at an alarming price. something we as parents can do to limit the fitness risks associated Nitrobuild Plus with obesity ought to accept the highest attention. as for adults we're on the street.


03/15/2017 2:48am

Intriguing and inspiring person Elaine Viets is. If only I will have a writer's fashion sense and form as she assist with academic writing. I needed to work very difficult to master my skills and I am prepared to share my tips and methods regarding how to do this fast and painfulness. You can keep studying here to locate a detailed descriptions. Best of luck!

03/15/2017 9:38pm

Vigor Excel relaxation days are also prescribed at the side of the sporting activities. failure to obey the protocol surrounding penis expansion sporting activities can motive Vigor Excel effects to fall underneath the expected tiers or worse damage.


03/16/2017 9:22pm

Nuvella Serum a small however crucial skin care tip.use sunscreen to guard your self from sun's hazardous radiation. you need to apply day-time moisturizers Nuvella Serum which have solar block built into them. employ them even though it is truly over cast.


03/17/2017 9:24pm

Testo Edge Ex one school of idea within the benefit muscle eating regimen area is to consume large amounts of protein whilst you build and address the body fats growth Testo Edge Ex later after you've got muscle to work with.


03/19/2017 9:54pm

Alpha Monster Advanced there are numerous ways you could method control of returned pain and muscle spasms at home. first you need to keep transferring. Alpha Monster Advanced you don’t want to visit mattress and lie nonetheless.


03/21/2017 12:56am

Endovex Male Enhancement reproductive even though later, saw palmetto is exceptional regarded to remedy hair loss and prostate enlargements. modern-day medication Endovex Male Enhancement has given us some of miracles in a bottle.


03/21/2017 9:51pm

Focus Max than your fitness plan can be commenced. assuming that the medical insurance plan price is inside your method the following element to find out is what Focus Max your health plan package deal covers. most fitness insurers.


03/23/2017 9:30pm

Endovex Male Enhancement a latest article in the health section of newsman reports that as cosmetic surgical procedure for guys will become greater mainstream Endovex Male Enhancement hundreds of sufferers are flocking to their docs for a system known.



Endovex Male Enhancement are recognized to paintings for numerous ailments. they claim to be made the usage of herbs and flora which have medicinal fee and Endovex Male Enhancement so are suitable for the body. without any harmful outcomes those natural capsules paintings.


03/26/2017 9:27pm

Andro Beast these are finished at the same time as preserving agglutinate a key nutrient for protein metabolism and stopping muscle deterioration.sodium is a mineral where Andro Beast it encourages muscle increase by using growing the muscle cell fluid volume.


03/27/2017 9:22pm

Andro Enhance make a tremendous impact on muscle growth. for satisfactory outcomes you ought to take 3-5 grams at once earlier than and after your exercise.Andro Enhance nitrite oxide or no2 turned into designed to growth electricity and energy.


03/28/2017 9:55pm

ACTUS the cells within the brain surrounding the visible environment will stay undeveloped. for that reason the brain need to mature with the intention to help ACTUS us with self-restoration and improvement.


03/29/2017 9:40pm

Enhance Mind IQ other than yourself there are other folks who we can say is intelligent creative and marked with super fruitfulness. pay attention to what others do and Enhance Mind IQ then emulate them. this is by some means what they call euro linguistic programming.


03/30/2017 9:28pm

Endovex the marketplace and might not need to supply your private and credit card statistics in incorrect arms. no person can deny that premature ejaculation Endovex subjects in the existence of the man affected by this condition.


03/31/2017 9:26pm

Force Factor VolcaNO dietary supplements are concentrated doses of nutrients. they are extracted from herbal meals sources you want to check this out Force Factor VolcaNO regularly and are in a shape in which the body is prepared to take in them.


04/02/2017 9:52pm

Ultimate Alpha Extreme expansion products even though the anecdotal testimonials are many. different breast enlargement methods make use of herbal Ultimate Alpha Extreme remedies or non-surgical devices. senna herbal tea approximately herbal.



Ultimate Alpha Extreme for the verbal exchange for the organization.everybody taking into account breast enhancement must meet with the plastic Ultimate Alpha Extreme healthcare professional ahead. choosing a plastic health care provider might not be an clean task.


04/03/2017 11:53pm

According to reports from the KSEEB board which was released by Minister in Karnataka State Kimmane Rathnakar, 79.16% students have cleared the examination.

Karnataka 10th class sslc results 2017

04/04/2017 9:32pm

Andronite Enhanced tract used the plant once they have been on looking journeys. the looking journeys in some instances last several weeks or maybe months.Andronite Enhanced the bushmen observed that the hoodie plant may.


04/05/2017 9:41pm

Endovex thongs have greater cloth on the returned at the same time as g-strings have only a string in that region. girls honestly love these ambitious and vivid portions Endovex of fabric and the studs absolutely discover.


04/06/2017 9:29pm

Ripped Max Muscle whether or not you operate unfastened exercising programs or workout applications that you use cautioned via private trainers Ripped Max Muscle will make no difference if you hire the hit method.the relaxation of the paintings.


04/09/2017 9:41pm

Xtreme Exo-Test this refers back to the entire manner of swing from when you approaching, top swing and down swing. however perform powerful swing has direct effect Xtreme Exo-Test to the route of the ball in preference to the space of the ball.


04/10/2017 9:09pm

Skin Novela that you have make you specify your problems and then suggest the products as a way to fit your pores and skin the great while casting off all of your skin related troubles. Skin Novela the company customized answers.


04/11/2017 9:19pm

Chantel St Claire a self made natural facial pores and skin care mask using herbal components out of your refrigerator pantry or maybe out of your lawn Chantel St Claire is an enriching useful and relaxing anti-getting older pores and skin rejuvenation treat.


04/12/2017 9:50pm

Ultra Boost Force while bodybuilding but we aim to on as lots muscle within the maximum time green and powerful manner possible. this is why the majority Ultra Boost Force of expert bodybuilders opt for a cut up in place of using complete body exercises.


04/13/2017 9:51pm

Dermabellix the actual secret of stunning pores and skin is protection from the outdoor and nourishment from inside integrate the two and you will have lovely skin . Dermabellix when you have blemishes and your skin is dry.


04/14/2017 10:15pm

Vlamorous a lot of state-of-the-art anti growing old skin care products come inside the form of serums creams and lotions. new versions are debuted all of the Vlamorous time every with its personal declare to repute approximately.


04/15/2017 5:01am

two favorites um but I just love the axiology lipstick formula and that not only is the packaging just like super like unique and amazing but the formula is really great the colors are really nice they don't have that many like true matte colors I think they might only have like one or two worth I know for short is like

04/16/2017 9:42pm

Endovex who has experienced breast growth can feel higher about sporting clothing together with swimsuits bikinis or outfitted blouses. large breasts make the Endovex waist look smaller and now in latest years.


04/17/2017 9:17pm

Endovex ladies may additionally enjoy losing the urge that is as a result of sure hormonal imbalances or maybe by means of pressure like too much work inside Endovex the workplace peer stress or even own family troubles.


04/18/2017 9:13pm

Avalure have it in its energetic shape that's proven effective at shielding you from the uva and uvb rays of the sun in addition to penetrating 7 layers of pores and skin to Avalure reduce wrinkles and provide antioxidants to all layers of the skin.


04/19/2017 9:12pm

Garcinia Shaping Pro this is in which humans get into hassle.it isn't actually confirmed if it is the hcg complement or the low calorie weight-reduction plan that causes Garcinia Shaping Pro the dramatic weight loss in individuals who do that diet regime.


05/05/2017 10:22pm

Master the project management framework with structured, tried and tested methodologies

06/22/2017 5:20am

bigo live is the best apk that you can download for free. This Article is all About Bigo Live Apk


2017 là sự bùng nổ của thị trường máy lọc nước ion kiềm giàu hydro

07/08/2017 5:41am

This IBPS Clerk Result helps you to attend the next round.Cut Off Marks There is the notification for the IBPS Clerk VII exam in the cadre of Clerk Positions


We always want to be the best at what we do. And this is evident in the way go about our work


We always want to be the best at what we do. And this is evident in the way go about our work

09/06/2017 5:59pm

If you have been injured in an automobile accident, work, or a slip and fall there is no better practice than Injury Care Chiropractic.


The Lighthouse Emotional Wellness Center was founded on an innovative and unique approach to couples counseling offered nowhere else in the Chicagoland area.

10/07/2017 1:49am

Beauti Queen amazing kolkata escorts agency alwyas ready for you at your doorstep. Beauti Queen provide you high profile independent girl in kolkata, escorts service in kolkata, kolkata escorts. If you are looking for the ultimate encounter in Kolkata then I am your sophisticated young Kolkata escorts that provides upscale companionship for making your night becomes true.

10/13/2017 2:38am

Jiya Roy is a high class luxury and premium independent escorts agency in Gurgaon offering sexy independent escort Girls, models and cheap rate call girls for incalls and outcalls and travel arrangements. Female companions available 24/7 for business events, tour guide and much more.

10/13/2017 11:06am

Gurgaonfemales.in offers highly educated model from Gurgaon and best Escorts service in Gurgaon through some of its sizzling Independent escorts in Gurgaon Call Girls who are available to customers 24*7.


Renu Das Kolkata Escorts Services has gorgeous females provides Independent Escorts Service in Kolkata call girls at 100% satisfaction with VIP models. Provided Kolkata escorts at our agency are professional in nature and are eager to serve you at your place.

10/17/2017 1:10am

In cases this way, an authoritative due process must be legitimately worked out. Guardians must know what their rights are in this procedure. Every gathering have a privilege to implement and watch. Any parent that finds the procedure unreasonably did should make certain of what the infractions are. From there on, it can be lifted to the higher government courts.


Leave a Reply